If you’re a regular reader, you’re probably not surprised to find that I don’t shop at Wal-Mart. It’s not just some knee-jerk reaction for me, though. I know Wal-Mart has changed or improved some of their environmental and human resources practices. I know people who work there and have no problems. I know people who shop there and benefit from the low prices.
I also know of several negative issues that lead me not to shop at Wal-Mart. Some of my reasons are personal, and some are more global.
Wal-Mart isn’t very close to where I live. The closest one is 5.3 miles away by car or bike. That’s further than I normally go to shop. I tend to stay within a mile or two of home.
Being inside a Wal-Mart store makes me crazy. They’re crowded, the shelves and excess merchandise tower over you, and the merchandise is often misplaced. The noise level is high, and the lines are long — even in the express lanes.
Wal-Mart doesn’t pay employees enough. There’s some controversy about this. People in some positions say they are getting paid enough. Others think it’s OK, because these jobs are often filled by students, retirees, and other part-timers anyway. I do think people deserve to be paid a living wage, but I’m not sure any more how to judge Wal-Mart in this area. Wal-Mart’s average hourly wage for U.S. workers in 2008 was $10.86.
Wal-Mart sells things too cheaply. What? That’s a problem? But Wal-Mart is providing a service to the community by keeping their prices low. NO. Sorry. There are several things wrong with this. How do they get the prices so low? By underpaying employees, by squeezing their suppliers (who are then forced to cut their costs somehow), and by selling merchandise that’s made in other countries where manufacturing and labor are cheaper (even cheaper than Wal-Mart wages).
I’m not OK with getting lower prices on the backs of other people. Also, people in the U.S. have now gotten the impression that we should always get the lowest possible prices on everything, and that we deserve to have things that are really luxury items at lower prices too. Remember when some people couldn’t afford TV’s, VCR’s, and video game systems? These things are now almost considered a human right in the U.S. Give us the lower prices, environment, salaries and human rights be damned! And meanwhile people wonder where all of the good manufacturing jobs have gone.
With all that said, I’m still shopping occasionally at Target (which is closer) for the things I need. Mostly little things, like contact lens solution and laundry detergent. Because they’re cheaper at Target. I’m told that Target is possibly more unpleasant than Wal-Mart as an employer. Hypocritical? Yeah. Alternative? I don’t know, is Fred Meyer any better?
SOURCES
Barry C. Lynn “Breaking the chain: The Anti-Trust case against Wal-Mart,” http://www.harpers.org/archive/2006/07/0081115
David Nassar, “Wal-Mart’s Wages Increase in China, Rollback in U.S.,” http://www.huffingtonpost.com/david-nassar/wal-marts-wages-increase_b_113118.html















